Skip to content
MAKE YOUR MOVE

Workflow automation

CRM Integration Project Brief: Data, Failures and Acceptance

By Midwest Digital 8 min read

White request cards and a work-item tray connected by a small metal bridge, beside a checklist and pencil.
Original illustration for Midwest Digital.

A useful CRM integration brief states which business event starts the transfer, which system owns each field, what changes are permitted, how failed work is recovered and what evidence counts as acceptance. “Connect our CRM” leaves these decisions open. Writing them down gives operations staff, developers and suppliers the same first release to discuss.

This guide turns an approved-request handoff into a concrete scope. It includes an original 14-case acceptance pack (JSON) that your technical reviewer can adapt. The pack contains synthetic examples and expected outcomes. No cases have been run against an integration, and none describe a Midwest Digital client result.

1. Define one handoff and its finish

Start with the work the connection should accomplish. Identify the source and destination products, editions, account boundaries, API access and any connector restrictions. Confirm these in the actual accounts before estimating implementation. A feature listed for a platform does not establish that your subscription, permissions or configuration supports it.

Use a bounded statement such as: “When a request in the CRM becomes approved, transfer its agreed fields to one work item in the operations system. Show failed transfers to a named operations owner.” Record the trigger, allowed update path and evidence of a completed transfer.

In our fictional example, the CRM owns approval and requested quantity. The operations system owns its internal work-item ID and fulfillment status. Receiving or queueing a request does not mean the transfer succeeded, and a successful transfer does not mean the business work is complete. These states need separate names in reports and alerts.

  • Included: new approved requests, later approved revisions, exception review and reconciliation.
  • Excluded from this example: historical migration, two-way synchronization, automatic deletion and fulfillment automation.
  • Decisions still required: what happens when approval is withdrawn, a request is cancelled or a source record disappears or a change arrives after downstream work starts. The example pack does not test those transitions; add rules and tests before including them in a real release.

If you are still deciding whether to buy a connector, configure a product or build a connection, use the software decision framework first. The same handoff and exceptions should be demonstrated by each candidate.

2. Map fields and name their owners

A mapping is more than a source-column and destination-column list. Include each field's purpose, allowed values, transformation, owner and behavior when missing or invalid. Limit the information transferred to what the workflow needs, and agree who can read payloads, logs and exception records and how long they are retained.

Fictional approved-request contract: adapt these rules to the chosen systems
FieldPurpose and authorityAcceptance rule
event_idIdentifies a delivered event for auditing.Required and nonempty; not the identity of the business work.
tenant_idNames the source account boundary.Must match the authenticated sender's allowed scope; a payload value alone grants no access.
request_idStable CRM reference for the request.Required; retain it on the destination item for lookup and reconciliation.
revisionCRM-owned version of the request.Positive integer that increases for each changed request in this fictional contract.
statusCRM-owned approval state.Only approved requests qualify for this transfer.
quantityCRM-owned requested quantity.Positive integer; invalid values go to correction rather than silent guessing.
Destination ID and completionOwned by the operations system.Capture the returned ID; reject attempts to set completion through this source payload.

The increasing revision number is an assumption of this example, not a universal CRM feature. If the selected source offers a different version mechanism, document that mechanism and how changes will be compared. Do not infer business order solely from delivery time or a convenient timestamp.

3. Separate delivery attempts from business identity

A repeated event should not create another work item. Two different events can also describe the same requested work. In this example, the stable business key combines the tenant, request and transfer action; the event ID remains a separate delivery reference. Compare the same tenant, request, revision, approval status and quantity when deciding whether business data is equal. A new delivery ID alone does not create new business work.

Ask the implementer to demonstrate concurrent delivery, not just a sequential retry. Two workers can both find “no existing item” before either writes. The chosen design needs a suitable atomic claim, destination uniqueness control or other proven way to prevent that race. Merely storing an event ID is not an exactly-once guarantee.

  • Same revision, same data: recognize the duplicate and preserve the existing destination item.
  • Older revision: retain the newer state and record why the incoming revision was ignored.
  • Newer approved revision: update the same item under the agreed version rule.
  • Same revision, conflicting data: hold for investigation; do not silently overwrite.

Provider behavior must be checked separately. For example, Stripe's webhook documentation describes duplicate events and delivery-order considerations, while its idempotency documentation defines that API's retry contract. These illustrate questions to ask; they do not establish how your CRM or operations system behaves. Verify key scope, retention and error handling with each provider.

4. Give failed and uncertain work an owner

A timeout is especially important: the destination may have saved the item even though the caller never received confirmation. Record the attempt and reconcile its outcome before another write that could duplicate work. Confirm the destination's uniqueness and lookup guarantees: an immediately empty lookup may reflect delayed visibility. An inconclusive lookup leaves an exception for review; it does not automatically authorize another create. If the destination cannot support safe identification or reconciliation, narrow the workflow or hold uncertain cases for review.

Define the recovery decision before enabling automatic retries
Observed conditionRequired handlingOwner to assign
Invalid or conflicting dataRetain a visible reason and correction path; do not retry unchanged invalid input indefinitely.Business data owner
Invalid sender or account mismatchReject the write and record an appropriate audit event without exposing sensitive payloads.Access or security owner
Rate limit before a writeUse bounded retries under the provider's rules; respect a supplied retry delay.Integration operator
Timeout with unknown write outcomeFind the existing item or establish that no write occurred before deciding to replay.Integration operator with business review when unresolved
Work item saved, notification failedRecover the failed side effect using its own recorded outcome; avoid recreating the work item.Notification or workflow owner

HTTP 429 indicates rate limiting and may include a Retry-After header. Agree a retry limit, escalation point and safe manual process for your integration. A 429 response or an empty analytics report alone does not prove whether a separate earlier operation succeeded.

Reconciliation compares an agreed set of eligible source records with destination records at a defined point or cutoff. Report missing and unexpected items separately. In a real changing dataset, account for in-flight work and your accepted delay before declaring a mismatch. An unexpected item is a reason to investigate, not permission to delete it.

5. Agree evidence before calling the integration complete

Give each acceptance case a starting state, input or fault, expected outcome, actual observation and reviewer. Use a sandbox or another approved test environment with synthetic data. Save correlation IDs and before-and-after evidence; redact secrets and unnecessary personal information.

  1. Normal transfer: one approved request produces one identifiable work item with the agreed values and a completed-transfer checkpoint.
  2. Concurrent duplicate: simultaneous equivalent events leave one item and no repeated configured business side effects.
  3. Revision handling: an older update cannot replace newer data; a newer approved revision updates the same item; equal-version conflicts stay visible.
  4. Timeout after commit: recovery identifies the already-saved item rather than creating another.
  5. Reconciliation gap: a frozen example with source requests 101, 102 and 103 and destination requests 101, 103 and 999 reports missing 102 and unexpected 999. Any repair requires authorization; it does not automatically remove 999.

Download all 14 synthetic acceptance cases (JSON), including invalid fields, sender and account checks, rate limiting, partial failure and worker restart. The file is a planning and review fixture, not executable test software. Its actual-result fields remain empty and every case is marked not_run. Replace the fictional contract with verified provider capabilities, add your excluded transitions and execute the adapted cases before claiming acceptance.

6. Complete the brief with operating decisions

Before requesting a final scope or approving a release, collect these items in the fillable software project brief (PDF) or your existing project document:

  • Named source and destination accounts, environments, access owners and confirmed API or connector capabilities.
  • One workflow, clear completion states, included updates and explicit exclusions.
  • Field mapping, authority, identity, version rules, permissions and data-retention decisions.
  • Normal and peak volumes, an agreed transfer-delay target and the evidence used to size the work.
  • Exception queue, alert routing, retry limits, authorized replay process and reconciliation schedule.
  • Acceptance cases with named reviewers, observed results and unresolved issues.
  • Release and rollback steps, support ownership and a process for provider or schema changes.

Measure the workflow separately from its business value. A successful transfer count is not a count of fulfilled requests or qualified leads. Use the automation ROI worksheet to distinguish released capacity from cash savings, with assumptions made explicit.

Midwest Digital's API and system integration service can help scope connected workflows. Discuss your integration project with the systems involved, a sanitized example request and the failed handoff you want to resolve. Do not include passwords, API keys or real customer records in your initial inquiry.